I have to really be not held on this one. I remember the meeting well, but the details and especially the date are hazy. I’m guessing 1978. It was announced that the Los Angeles and San Francisco floors would be combined with the San Francisco floors moving to Los Angeles. WTF? Options members said they hadn’t voted on anything like that! The PSE was not a democracy and there were provisions in the Constitution (Rule 6) that The Board could take any measures deemed necessary for the good of the Exchange. This still didn’t sit well with members who had just moved to S.F. “I never voted on it!” some insisted. I think the Exchange had the meeting to let members vent, and then they would go through with the move anyway.
The meeting was held in a ballroom at the Embarcadero Hyatt. PSE executives and Board members were on a small stage. Many of the members, especially on the Equity floor, had no problem with moving to L.A. Many of them were from L.A. and it would be a return home for them.
I had to admit that when I first moved to California I didn’t know that much about the rivalry between Los Angeles and San Francisco besides the Giants vs. Dodgers thing. Many of us were just getting used to living in S.F. and the idea of moving to L.A. was more repulsive than when we first arrived. I always remember a big trader I knew in L.A. asking me, “Why did you EVER move to San Francisco?” I reminded him that Chicago winters were not that pleasant.
There was a lot of animosity and tension between Exchange execs and members, especially the Market Makers. By now, there were more Market Makers from Chicago and New York. They were not used to PSE ways. An Exchange President, Dean Cluff, had once commented that PSE executives were used to telling employees and even members what to do. They were not used to being questioned.
At the meeting, the PSE executives laid out their rationale for the move. Having two floors was a bit absurd, even then. There was some discussion of the problems the Options floor was having.
It’s hard to remember exactly how it happened, but things became a bit heated. Exchange fees and executive salaries were brought up. Someone said that the Market Makers were really running the Exchange by risking capital. (I don’t think they used the “liquidity provider” term yet.) One executive said that market makers had made that career choice and should live with it. This set off some yelling from the Option members. There had been some talk on the Options floor of trying to “be cool” during the meeting. “They won’t listen if we’re all yelling at them.” Most of that went out the window as the meeting went on. I can’t remember all that spoke out, but there were two that stood out.
An unlikely ally spoke. Marvin Breen was usually at odds with the Market Makers, to say the least. So, it was surprising when he spoke up and said, “Despite my colleagues appearance, they are businessman.” He also mentioned that there were professionals among the Market Makers including honored academics. The point was that they were businessmen who also looked at the bottom line.
Stu Blackman had been an Independent broker on the CBOE and was relatively new to the San Francisco floor. Quite a character. There are many stories about him. To say the least he was frank. “I know how to talk to these fuckers.” He took center stage and told the executives, “Let’s face it gentlemen, money talks and bullshit walks!” I can’t remember the exact context. Those onstage really started to squirm.
I think Lee Wilson was a Board Member at the time. He was on the stage. He did yell, “Move back to Chicago!” It may have been aimed at Stu, but it was a bad time for the comment. The members opposing the move exploded.
The comment was revealing. It was typical of the split between Options and Equity members. From day one they called us “Option Scum” in that San Francisco provincial way. The Equity floor did stay open at least an hour after Options trading hours. They tried to stop Options members from crossing the Equity floor after the Options close. Too disruptive, or something.
Of course I remember the more dramatic highlights. The political background is hazy. I doubt it was because of the meeting, but of course the merger of the two floors did not take place.
Anyone out there with more details on this now ancient squabble?